Facebook Ads for Criminal Defense & DUI Lawyers: Data-Driven Guide
Nobody scrolls Facebook looking for a DUI lawyer at 2 AM after an arrest. Let's be honest about that.
When someone gets arrested, their spouse Googles "criminal defense lawyer near me" or calls the number on the bail bondsman's card. That's high-intent behavior, and Google captures it.
So why does Facebook work for criminal defense? Because the real game isn't catching people in crisis—it's being the name they remember when crisis hits.
Criminal defense and DUI cases have unique dynamics that make Facebook advertising remarkably effective—but not for the reasons most agencies claim.
Why Facebook Works for Criminal Defense (When Google Feels Impossible)
Google Ads for criminal defense keywords is a bloodbath. "DUI lawyer near me" can cost $150-300 per click in competitive markets. You're fighting established firms with massive budgets, and the math gets brutal fast.
Facebook is different.
Less competition, better targeting: Most criminal defense firms pour everything into Google, leaving Facebook relatively untapped. The firms that figure out Facebook targeting find lead costs 40-60% lower than Google in the same market.
The family member factor: The person who hires the lawyer often isn't the person who got arrested. Spouses, parents, and siblings make the hiring decision. But here's the key—they DO Google when it happens. Facebook's role is different: it's how you become the name they recognize and trust when they search. Brand recognition built over months on Facebook converts to signed cases when crisis hits.
Mobile-first behavior: When someone gets a call that their husband was just arrested for DUI, they don't walk to their home office and open a browser. They search on their phone. Facebook is built for mobile. Your ad meets them where they already are.
Typical ROI: Firms running optimized Facebook campaigns for criminal defense report 200-500% ROI. That's not a typo. The combination of lower competition and precise targeting creates real arbitrage opportunities.
Geographic Targeting That Actually Works
You can't target "people who just got arrested" on Facebook. Meta removed sensitive targeting options related to legal status in 2024 as part of their ongoing privacy updates. But you can get remarkably close.
The 1-Mile Radius Strategy
Target locations where your ideal clients congregate—before and after an incident:
Nightlife districts: Draw a 1-mile radius around bars, clubs, and entertainment areas. These are DUI hotspots. Someone who was in the area on a Friday night and sees your ad on Saturday morning is far more likely to need your services.
Courthouse proximity: Target people who've recently been near criminal courthouses. Not everyone at the courthouse is a defendant, but geographic presence suggests connection to the system.
Jail and detention center radius: Family members pick people up. They wait in parking lots. They're nearby during visitation hours. A 1-mile radius around detention facilities reaches people in active crisis.
The Nightlife Timing Stack
Combine geographic targeting with time-based delivery:
- Friday-Saturday nights: Increase bids 50-100% for audiences in nightlife areas
- Sunday-Monday mornings: Heavy delivery to the same areas—this catches the "morning after" search behavior
- Weekend nights overall: 70% of DUI arrests happen Friday through Sunday
This isn't about showing ads to drunk people. It's about reaching the sober family members who need help after something goes wrong.
Timing Your Ad Delivery for Maximum Impact
The 72-Hour Window
Criminal defense decisions happen fast. Unlike personal injury where someone might research attorneys for weeks, a DUI arrest creates immediate urgency. The family needs a lawyer for the arraignment, which might be Monday morning.
Primary delivery windows:
- Friday 10 PM – Sunday 6 AM (during arrest hotspots)
- Saturday 7 AM – 2 PM (morning-after searches)
- Sunday all day (preparing for Monday court)
- Monday 6 AM – 10 AM (pre-arraignment panic)
After-Hours Emphasis
Most law firms turn their ads off at 5 PM. This is exactly when your competitors go dark and demand spikes.
Set your campaigns to increase delivery:
- 8 PM – 2 AM (evening arrests, DUI checkpoints)
- Weekends broadly
- Holidays (DUI checkpoints increase, arrests spike)
The firm that appears when someone needs help at 11 PM on Saturday wins the case. The firm whose ads only run 9-5 Monday-Friday loses it to someone else.
Ad Creative That Converts (Without Looking Desperate)
The Urgency Balance
Criminal defense marketing requires careful calibration. You need to convey urgency—because the situation is urgent—without appearing predatory or ambulance-chasy.
What works:
"Arrested? We Answer 24/7. Free Consultation."
"Your First Call Matters. Licensed Criminal Defense Attorney Standing By."
"Don't Face the Court Alone. Speak to an Attorney Tonight."
What doesn't work:
"ARRESTED??? CALL NOW!!! DON'T GO TO JAIL!!!"
"Your Life Is RUINED Unless You Act FAST!!!"
The difference is confidence versus panic. Your ad should feel like a calm, capable professional extending a hand—not a salesperson exploiting fear.
Targeting Family Members
Since family often makes the hiring decision, create ad variants that speak directly to them:
"Need Help for a Family Member? We're Here."
"Spouse or Child Arrested? Know Your Options Tonight."
"One Call Can Change Everything. 24/7 Criminal Defense Consultation."
Visual Creative Guidelines
What converts:
- Professional headshot of the attorney (builds trust)
- Office environment shots (establishes legitimacy)
- Calm, authoritative imagery
- Navy blue, dark gray, and white color schemes
What fails:
- Stock photos of handcuffs or jail cells (feels predatory)
- Overly dramatic imagery
- Bright red "WARNING" style graphics
- Generic "scales of justice" clip art
The person clicking your ad is scared. Your creative should make them feel like help is available—not amplify their fear.
Landing Pages Built for Mobile Crisis
The 60-Second Rule
Someone clicking your Facebook ad at 11 PM on Saturday has one question: "Can you help me right now?"
Your landing page needs to answer that question within 60 seconds. Not explain your fee structure. Not list every type of case you handle. Just: "Yes, help is available. Here's how to reach us."
Essential elements:
- Massive, tappable phone number (visible without scrolling)
- "24/7" or "Available Now" prominently displayed
- Single contact form (name, phone, brief description)
- Chat widget for immediate response
- Brief attorney credentialing (licensed, years of experience, results)
Remove:
- Long paragraphs of text
- Multiple practice area pages
- Fee calculators
- Anything that slows down the path to contact
Mobile-First Design Priorities
85%+ of your Facebook traffic will be mobile. Design for that reality:
- Phone number must be tap-to-call
- Forms need minimal fields (name, phone, that's it)
- Page load under 3 seconds
- Everything above the fold that matters
- Chat or text option prominent
Test your landing page at 2 AM on your own phone. If getting to a human takes more than three taps, you're losing cases.
Working Within Platform Restrictions
What You Can't Target
Meta's 2024 updates removed several targeting options relevant to criminal defense:
- Legal status or criminal history
- Substance use or addiction
- Financial stress indicators
- Bail bonds interest (removed)
Attempting to circumvent these restrictions through interest stacking or lookalike audiences based on excluded categories will get your account suspended.
What You Can Target
Demographics that index high for criminal defense need:
- Age 25-54 (peak DUI age range)
- Parents of teenagers/young adults (frequently hire for children)
- Homeowners in nightlife-adjacent zip codes
Interests that remain available:
- Legal topics broadly
- Court system interest
- Local news consumption
- Driving-related interests (carefully)
Behavioral signals:
- Recent life events (moving, job changes—stress correlates)
- Travel to your geographic area
- Engagement with local business content
Custom Audiences That Work
Build custom audiences from:
- Website visitors (especially landing page visitors who didn't convert)
- Video viewers (anyone who watched 50%+ of your ad)
- Page engagers (people who interacted with your Facebook page)
These warm audiences convert at 3-5x the rate of cold traffic. Someone who visited your site once but didn't call is far more likely to convert on the second touch.
Retargeting: The Second Chance That Converts
Why Retargeting Matters for Criminal Defense
First-touch conversion rates for criminal defense are often 2-5%. That means 95%+ of people who click your ad don't convert immediately.
But they bookmarked you. They saved your number. They're "thinking about it."
Retargeting catches them when they move from "researching" to "ready to act."
Building Your Retargeting Funnel
Layer 1: Website visitors (all)
- Show general branding ads
- Frequency: 2-3 times per week for 14 days
Layer 2: Landing page visitors (no conversion)
- More urgent messaging: "Still need help? We're here 24/7"
- Frequency: Daily for 7 days
Layer 3: Form abandoners
- Direct call-to-action: "Finish your consultation request"
- Frequency: 2x daily for 3 days
Exclusions: Always exclude people who converted. Showing "Need a criminal lawyer?" ads to your current client is a bad look.
Budget and Scaling Strategy
Starting Budget Framework
Testing phase (first 30 days):
- $50-100/day across 3-4 ad variants
- Test creative, audiences, and placements
- Don't optimize for conversions yet—optimize for learning
Scaling phase (days 31-60):
- Increase budget 20-30% per week on winners
- Kill underperformers ruthlessly
- Add retargeting layer
Mature campaigns:
- Top performers at $200-500/day in medium markets
- Retargeting at 10-15% of total budget
- Creative refresh every 4-6 weeks
Cost Benchmarks
Expect these ranges for criminal defense/DUI:
| Metric | Low Range | Medium | High |
|---|---|---|---|
| CPM (cost per 1,000 impressions) | $15 | $30 | $60 |
| CPC (cost per click) | $3 | $8 | $15 |
| Cost per lead | $35 | $75 | $150 |
| Cost per signed case | $300 | $800 | $2,000 |
These vary dramatically by market. Los Angeles is 3x more expensive than Omaha. Adjust expectations accordingly.
Compliance and Ethical Considerations
Bar Association Advertising Rules
Criminal defense advertising is subject to the same state bar rules as all legal advertising:
- No guarantees: Never promise outcomes ("We'll get your case dismissed")
- Accurate specialization claims: Only claim specialization if certified
- Required disclaimers: Include "This is an advertisement" or equivalent where required by your jurisdiction
- Fee accuracy: If mentioning fees, be precise and complete
Platform-Specific Compliance
Meta requires:
- "Paid for by" disclaimers for social issues ads (criminal justice can qualify)
- No discriminatory targeting practices
- No claims that can't be substantiated
Ethical Targeting Boundaries
Just because you can target something doesn't mean you should:
Appropriate:
- Geographic targeting near relevant locations
- Time-based delivery during high-need periods
- Interest targeting on legal topics
- Custom audiences from your own website
Questionable:
- Targeting support groups for substance abuse
- Lookalike audiences based on past criminal defense clients
- Interest stacking that effectively recreates prohibited categories
When in doubt, ask: "Would I be comfortable explaining this targeting strategy to a bar ethics committee?" If no, don't do it.
Making It All Work Together
The Complete Campaign Setup
Campaign 1: Cold Prospecting
- Objective: Lead generation or traffic
- Targeting: Geographic + demographic + timing
- Budget: 70% of total
- Creative: Professional, authority-building
Campaign 2: Warm Retargeting
- Objective: Conversions
- Targeting: Website visitors, video viewers
- Budget: 20% of total
- Creative: More urgent, action-focused
Campaign 3: Hot Retargeting
- Objective: Conversions
- Targeting: Landing page visitors, form abandoners
- Budget: 10% of total
- Creative: Direct "complete your request" messaging
Weekly Optimization Checklist
- Review cost per lead by ad set
- Pause underperforming creatives (CPC 2x average)
- Refresh frequency caps if creative fatigue showing
- Check geographic performance by region
- Verify landing page load times on mobile
- Review conversion lag (how long from click to call?)
The 24/7 Reality
Here's the uncomfortable truth: Facebook ads for criminal defense only work if someone answers when people call.
You can run the most sophisticated targeting in the world. You can have perfect ad creative. You can build beautiful mobile landing pages.
But if the call at 11 PM on Saturday goes to voicemail, you lost the case. The family member will keep scrolling until they find someone who picks up.
Before scaling your Facebook ads, fix your intake. Answer every call. Respond to every form within 5 minutes. Have someone available 24/7 during campaign delivery windows.
The leads are out there. The question is whether you're ready to catch them when they arrive.
Related Facebook Ads Guides
Looking for more on Facebook advertising for law firms? Explore our complete series:
-
Strategy & Planning
-
Technical Setup
-
Practice Area Guides
-
Creative & Format
Irfad Imtiaz is Director of Technology at My Legal Academy and Co-Founder & CTO at Ranql. He has personally helped 400+ law firms implement AI and automation systems.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do Facebook ads cost for criminal defense lawyers?
Facebook ads for criminal defense typically cost $3-15 per click, $35-150 per lead, and $300-2,000 per signed case. These costs are 40-60% lower than Google Ads for the same keywords. Costs vary significantly by market—Los Angeles can be 3x more expensive than smaller cities like Omaha.
Can I target people who were arrested on Facebook?
No, Meta removed sensitive targeting options related to legal status and criminal history in 2024. However, you can effectively reach your audience by targeting geographic proximity to courts, jails, and nightlife areas, combined with time-based delivery during peak arrest periods (Friday-Sunday nights). You can also build custom audiences from website visitors and retarget them.
What's the best time to run DUI lawyer ads on Facebook?
The optimal delivery windows for DUI ads are: Friday 10 PM – Sunday 6 AM (during peak arrest times), Saturday 7 AM – 2 PM (morning-after searches), Sunday all day (preparing for Monday court), and Monday 6 AM – 10 AM (pre-arraignment panic). 70% of DUI arrests happen Friday through Sunday, so concentrate your budget on weekends.
Should I target the accused person or their family members?
Target both, but prioritize family members. The person who hires the criminal defense lawyer is often not the person who was arrested—spouses, parents, and siblings frequently make the hiring decision while their loved one is in custody. Create ad variants that speak directly to family members: 'Need Help for a Family Member? We're Here.'
What's the 1-mile radius strategy for criminal defense Facebook ads?
Draw 1-mile radius targeting around locations where your ideal clients congregate: nightlife districts (bars, clubs, entertainment areas), criminal courthouses, and jails/detention centers. People who've recently been near these locations are more likely to need criminal defense services—either the accused or family members picking them up or visiting.
What ROI can I expect from Facebook ads for criminal defense?
Firms running optimized Facebook campaigns for criminal defense report 200-500% ROI. This high return comes from lower competition (most firms focus on Google), precise geographic and timing-based targeting, and reaching family members who make quick hiring decisions. The key is having 24/7 intake to capture leads when they call.
What should my criminal defense Facebook landing page include?
Your landing page must answer 'Can you help me right now?' within 60 seconds. Essential elements: massive tap-to-call phone number visible without scrolling, '24/7' or 'Available Now' prominently displayed, single contact form with minimal fields (name, phone only), chat widget for immediate response, and brief attorney credentials. Remove long paragraphs, multiple pages, and fee calculators—anything that slows the path to contact.
Book a Revenue Leak Audit
Most law firms lose 30-50% of potential clients due to gaps in their intake process. Find out exactly where—and how to fix it.
Join 1,400+ law firms that grew with My Legal Academy
Related Articles
Google Ads for Lawyers: The Complete 2026 Guide
Legal services has the highest CPC in Google Ads at $8.58 average—and $50-$500+ for competitive PI keywords. Here's the complete playbook: real cost data by practice area, campaign structure that works, Quality Score optimization, and the mistakes that waste 20-40% of most law firm ad budgets.
Law Firm Marketing Budget: How to Allocate Spend Across Channels in 2026
Real budget benchmarks and allocation frameworks based on data from thousands of law firms. Learn how much to spend, where to allocate it, and the costly mistakes that drain marketing budgets.
Marketing Attribution for Law Firms: Track What Actually Drives Signed Cases
49% of law firms allocate budget to marketing, but 22% can't measure what works. Here's how to set up attribution tracking that connects ad spend to signed cases—not just clicks and calls.